Tuesday, July 24, 2007

Harry Potter

I was aware about the Harry Potter & the Deathly Hallows leak for days before I decided to check it out. First, I read the (photographed) epilogue which I found too sugary, with no mentioned of professions, practically only about who has how many kids. So I thought it couldn't be the real book.

Then came Saturday, boy was I wrong! I had the real book all along. It took me about 18 hours to read through, longer than my usual 10 hours because I still read some other things in between, plus cooking, plus packing. It was an interesting read, full of actions, joy, laughter, and sadness. Until the epilogue, that is. She could have spent more pages on a better epilogue. So what, 20-30 more pages won't kill you if you already have been through more than 500 pages anyway. Such an anticlimax. It's like JK reminds me again that HP is a children's book, where a story has to end happily ever after. Gosh, I still couldn't believe she did that. I felt cheated in the end. So, my advice is: don't read the epilogue.

While I am glad my hunch on Snape & Dumbledore came true, JK didn't mention anything about how the wizarding world see both figures after the events. Was there any exoneration? I wonder what happen to the Dursleys, JK hinted that we would know more about them in this book, but she failed to let us know what Petunia did to Dudley (remember Dumbledore said something about it in the previous book?). I wish she said more about the transformation of some of the characters (e.g. Neville, Draco), what happened in Hogwarts while the trio were away and why didn't Harry/Ron/Hermione use their DA coins. Lots of questions to answer, leaving room for (a) spin-off(s).

4 comments:

Unknown said...

1) no sploier warning?!?!?

2) it is a kids book, pure and simple...

triesti said...

Did I say that much?? Oops..Sorry

btw, thx for the link

Nana Podungge said...

Huehehehehe ...
In fact, I haven't read any single HP book, LOL, just not curious yet. But my daughter is crazy for it. And after reading this comment of yours, I will not tell her that it has happy ending. :) She has got a copy of the complete book in English, but she hasn't started reading it. :) You know, the books haven't reached Indonesia. Oh well, I am not sure though. :)

Pojok Hablay said...

feminist, harry potter has arrived safe and sound in Indonesia, as any other place in the world. been locked my self.

triesti...
my analysis about snape is sooo right. happy!

I am now counting the day to be able to re-read it